San Luis Obispo County DA asks governor not to commute California’s death sentences

October 25, 2026

SLO District Attorney Dan Dow

By JOSH FRIEDMAN

San Luis Obispo County District Attorney Dan Dow on Friday sent a letter to California Gov. Gavin Newsom urging him to reject a blanket commutation of all 563 death sentences in California.

Newsom is reportedly considering mass clemency for death row inmates in California. Dow, in turn, penned a letter to Newsom requesting that the governor reject a blanket commutation of California’s death sentences. In the letter, Dow also urged Newsom to name the victims in every clemency decision he makes.

Dow argued a single order commuting all death sentences in California would set aside hundreds of individualized judgments without examining the facts of any of them.

“A blanket commutation would be a slap in the face to every special-circumstance murder victim and the loved ones they left behind,” Dow said in a statement. “Justice is always individualized. It depends on the particular facts and circumstances of each crime, each defendant, and each victim.

“In our criminal and victim justice system, every victim deserves to be treated equally, and always fairly, with dignity and respect,” Dow added. “The government of California is We the People, not one person overruling the voters in every capital case at once.”

Dow argued in the letter that every death sentence in California requires a first-degree murder conviction, at least one special circumstance found true beyond a reasonable doubt and a separate penalty phase in which a jury weighed the aggravating and mitigating evidence and chose death. Each death sentence was then reviewed by the trial judge and sent on automatic appeal to the California Supreme Court.

The San Luis Obispo County District Attorney also noted California voters have supported the death penalty whenever they have been asked: restoring it in 1972, expanding it in 1978 and rejecting its repeal in 2012 and 2016.

In his letter, Dow mentioned the cases of two inmates who were sentenced to death in San Luis Obispo County — Rex Krebs and Michael Whisenhunt — who Dow says would benefit from a blanket commutation.

Krebs kidnapped, raped and murdered Cal Poly student Rachel Newhouse, as well as Cuesta College student Aundria Crawford. A jury returned a death verdict for each of Krebs’s murders, and the California Supreme Court unanimously affirmed the judgment in 2019.

Whisenhunt tortured and murdered 19-month-old Kesha Gurke in Paso Robles. A jury found the torture special circumstance true and returned a death verdict for Whisenhunt. The state Supreme Court affirmed the judgment in 2008.

Since both inmates have more than one felony conviction, the California Constitution does not allow the governor to commute their sentences unless the state Supreme Court reviews each case and recommends it with four justices agreeing. The California Constitution requires individualized reviews in these cases, Dow wrote in his letter.

 


Loading...
7 Comments

This is what threat to democracy looks like. The california voters in 2012 and 2016 voted against two propostions that would have eliminated the death penalty. Remebr this when Governor Hair Gel runs for president.


The King that the blue hairs love, Gavin Nuisance and now Xavier Becerra.


The low-IQ Libocrat hypocrisy is embarrassing to REAL Americans that are unlike those anti-Americans.


Speed up the end game of ALL condemned criminals.


STOP wasting our taxpayer money, while allowing them to continue to steal our O2.


Step aside, I’ll pull the lever, sooner rather than later to finally provide solice to the family/ies of the victim(s).


Granting clemency to these murderers would be a slap in the face of every juror and prosecutor that did the hard work getting a death penalty conviction or verdict.

Our system is broken if one elected office holder can nullify the thousands of hours of hard work and agonizing deliberation of the people who put forth their best effort to make sure Justice was served. Five hundred and six thee juries of twelve, six thousand seven hundred and fifty six jurors were not wrong.


Another option might be all-female injection teams, and a robust Kalshi market to finance the extra attempts.


What’s with the down votes? Shouldn’t these abominations be subject to horrendous pain and inept attempts at execution from women?


I don’t always agree with Dow, but on this, absolutely. Thank you.