Supreme Court ruling strengthens parental rights

October 16, 2026

District Trustee Kenney Enney

OPINION by KENNEY ENNEY

To the parents and families of Paso Robles Joint Unified School District. I am writing to you directly because the Paso Robles Joint Unified School District (PRJUSD) Board of Trustees and district staff have chosen to not immediately update and publish clear notice of important parental rights that flow from a recent U.S. Supreme Court order.

At the Oct. 13 district board meeting, I attempted to have the board immediately align our policies with the U.S. Supreme Court Mirabelli orders and California School Board Associations (CSBA) updated policies and to notify district parents of their Constitutional rights which the district has chosen not to highlight in the annual “Parental Notifications.”

In a 5-1 decision, the majority of the board declined to do so, preferring to rely on more staff training and await further CSBA materials, meaning that most likely staff will inform families and parents of these decisions after Christmas.

I disagree. Parental rights should not depend on whether a parent happens to ask the right question or whether individual staff members choose to volunteer information.

In March 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court issued an emergency order in Mirabelli v. Bonta. The Court partially restored a federal district court permanent injunction that protects parents’ rights under the “Free Exercise Clause” and the “Due Process Clause” of the Constitution. The injunction is currently in effect as to parents while the full appeal continues in the Ninth Circuit.

The CSBA has summarized the practical impact in its Sept. 2026 newsletter, “Mirabelli v. Bonta: The Impact on School Policy”, and has updated its sample board policies and administrative regulations accordingly. I encourage you to review the CSBA article, communicate directly with your child’s school and the district about any concerns regarding gender identity, names, pronouns, or related treatment, and assert your rights if you object.

You may also request access to your child’s education records under Family Education Rights Protection Act.

Under the Supreme Court and district court orders, and as reflected in CSBA’s guidance:

(1) Parents and guardians have the right to object to any treatment of a student by the district that is inconsistent with the student’s sex assigned at birth.

(2) The district is prohibited from enforcing any policies, laws, guidance, or training that would permit or require employees to lie to or mislead a parent or guardian about a student’s gender presentation at school.

(3) The orders include an explicit exception: disclosure is not required where there is a reasonable belief that doing so would endanger the well-being of the student, but requires court involvement.

When California nondiscrimination law and the Mirabelli orders are read together, the district is:

(1) Required to defer to a student’s asserted gender identity and treat the student accordingly unless the parent or guardian objects;

(2) Prohibited from undermining the parent’s or guardian’s ability to object to such treatment; and

(3) Forbidden from proactively interfering with the parent’s or guardian’s awareness of a student’s asserted gender identity unless there is a reasonable belief that doing so would endanger the student’s well-being.

CSBA has updated its sample Board Policy and Administrative Regulation 5145.3 (Nondiscrimination/Harassment) to state, among other things:

(1) The district shall accept a student’s assertion of gender identity and treat the student consistently with that identity unless the parent/guardian objects.

(2) Personnel shall address a student by the student’s requested name and pronoun unless the parent/guardian objects.

(3) Personnel shall use the same name and pronouns when speaking with the student at school and when speaking with the parent/guardian, unless there is a reasonable belief that doing so would endanger the student’s well-being.

(4) Students may access sex-segregated facilities (restrooms, locker rooms) and participate in sex-segregated programs and activities consistent with their asserted gender identity unless the parent/guardian objects.

What this means for families, especially those whose children may be experiencing gender dysphoria, is if your child is asserting a gender identity different from their sex at birth, requesting a different name or pronouns, or seeking to use opposite-sex facilities or programs, you have the right to be accurately informed (subject only to the endangerment exception) and the right to object.

The district and its employees may not be required, or trained to conceal this information from you or to treat your child in a manner contrary to your direction simply because the student has not consented.

The safety carve-out exists for genuine cases in which disclosure would reasonably threaten a student’s well-being; it is not a general license to withhold information from parents in ordinary circumstances, and requires court involvement.

These rights are rooted in parents’ longstanding constitutional authority to direct the upbringing and religious development of their children. The Supreme Court has indicated that the challenged California policies likely interfere with those rights more substantially than policies previously found to require strict scrutiny.  Please spread the word.

 


Loading...
9 Comments

Bonta is on a real losing streak lately, maybe the US Constitution does apply in California.


You were elected to be a member of a school board. 1 of 6 voices. School boards are effective when they act as a single body. Their vote is the official position of the school district. You have a tendency to run to the press when on the losing side of a vote. You are not a trustworthy partner to the other board members. To be an effective board member you need to build a consensus with the other board members. Work with them. Productively.

I am sure you are a pleasure to serve (volunteer) with on the board.


No. A panel should NOT consist of like minded people. The fact that ONE person objects to a bad idea, is good for society.


Will we hear these same words from you, when the Paso School Board unanimously votes for free use of drugs at school? Skinny dipping is a healthy school activity? Having beer available at the cafeteria is good for children?


Thank GOD for Mr. Enney’s vote, which keeps foolish people like you away from our kids.


Oooh must’ve touched a nerve, huh?


With good estate planning by parents, grandparents, and great grandparents, all of this child abuse can be immediately, completely, and permanently avoided.


That makes…..no sense at all.


Apparently downvoting “good estate planning” makes sense to an educrat mob hellbent on preserving a system that abuses children.


Or maybe they have no clue about what estate planning can do?


Hey, no fair. My daughter’s away at law school (where BTW the govschool kids have a difficult time surviving) and i only have my wife to help with upvoting. How can i win against an entire coven of teachers?