Front Page  »  

Earth Fest is co-opting our beloved Earth Day

April 22, 2025

Offshore wind energy protest in Morro Bay

OPINION by MANDY DAVIS

Every year, I have looked forward to getting together with my earth and ocean loving friends to celebrate our love of and commitment to a healthy and sustainable future. We all tabled booths, learned openly from each other, listened to music and danced the celebration of our interconnection and our joy at the beauty of life on a healthy planet.

Sandra Marshal was inspirational as an organizer and a leader, remaining open to all aspects of environmental exploration and steering clear of judgement and censorship of ideologies and information honestly proffered to the public.

Sadly, all of that has changed in an indication of a sign of the times…extreme bipartisanship, blatant censorship of opposing and valid viewpoints, and the wholesale co-opting of what once was a thriving environmental movement. A movement where infant NGOs really protected the earth at all costs instead of selling out to huge “green” industries with empty promises of “renewable, sustainable and environmentally sound” energy sources.

This year, Earth Fest , with the SLO Climate Coalition and Eco-SLO at its helm, has undermined the historic impetus behind the Earth Day Celebration and have made it their own public opportunity to push a politically and industry driven agenda; one that is clearly noted in their online agenda, mission statement and demands of all participating vendors. Earth Fest is no longer a forum for celebration of working towards Earth’s thrive ability.

Instead, it is exclusionary… focused on a specific agenda backed by political entities, wind energy corporations, coalitions and well-funded “environmental” NGO’s pushing for an unrealistic, and unattainable “Net Zero” energy agenda that according to one set of data will help mitigate a coming “climate catastrophe.”

In their minds there is no room for opposing views and valid supportable information that invites a different conclusion than their own. Most certainly there is no room to allow for any input from other environmental NGO’s that oppose the implementation of these bogus “renewable” industries.

REACT Alliance was formed two years ago to assure that earth friendly energy sources be implemented on the Central Coast and to oppose offshore wind after extensive research into the viability of the technology.

Last year we applied for and graciously received approval to provide information in a booth as a caring and important voice in our community at the Earth Day Celebration.

This year we were summarily turned down with this response forthcoming.” After careful consideration, the EarthFest Advisory Committee has decided to decline your application for a booth at this year’s event.

While we welcome diverse perspectives on offshore wind development and other sustainability topics, our commitment to fact-based dialogue and responsible information sharing is paramount. Given REACT Alliance’s history of spreading misinformation, as well as the presence of misleading information currently on your website, we are unable to approve your participation.”

In other words…we don’t agree with you and won’t tolerate any opposition accordingly. To state the presence of misinformation without any specificity is a cheap shot belying a lack of intellectual curiosity or clarity.

To be clear…this year’s Earth Fest is a thinly disguised attempt to guide the public into an uncontested and one sided view of what is truly sustainable and earth friendly by a co-opted group of climate activists, ill-informed public officials and a whole slew of folks that have been financially and politically motivated to support an industry that will forever decimate our coastal environment both onshore and offshore.

“Earth Fest” just by its focus and existence violates one of the major ecological principles…the importance of diversity to the thrive ability of our species and above all, the health and wellbeing of our Earth and Oceans.

Earth Day has sadly been politicized and co-opted by Earth Fest here in SLO County. It is no longer the open and joyful celebration of diversity within a community that is working to better a beleaguered earth and to find truly long-term ecologically viable solutions.

It has become a vehicle to drive an agenda and to undermine intellectual curiosity and information sharing. It is the ultimate example of how much our society is guided by divisiveness, politicization and a desire to censor and demean.

I ask all of you that remember what Earth Day truly is at its core to challenge this new direction, boycott the event and its sponsors, and to recommit to being a true environmental warrior. Live your lives according to an ethic that makes you personally responsible for your footprint on this earth.

Stay intellectually open and curious and fight like hell for the health of our Earth and her Oceans.

Mandy Davis is the president of REACT Alliance and a Morro Bay resident. REACT Alliance is a local organization established to educate and inform the public about the issues involved with offshore wind.

 


Loading...
Subjects:     
Related:


7 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Boycott seems very selfish and anti-productive. If this lady wants a different kind of festival, let her create one and let the people who are doing the work for this other event do it the way they want.


-5

Oh, you mean like a festival that’s been held every year since this year? Or do you mean a festival that’s open to all opinions versus just the opinions the Slo climate coalition wants to spread?


4

Congratulations, Ms. Davis, you’ve won the battle. The likelihood of an offshore wind farm in Morro Bay is almost zero now and for at least several years to come. Without federal support, it’s a non-starter. The new administration has made it quite clear that it is abandoning any pretense of doing anything to mitigate carbon emissions in the U.S. And while California stays in the game, its resources are limited and even CARB has recently raised the white flag on some of its upcoming regulations in the face of EPA opposition.


So, I think the tourist trade is safe, no matter whether the U.S. burns oil, coal or brimstone (if I understood your bio on the REACT website, that appears to be your primary concern, though I doubt a wind farm far out to sea would have impacted Morro Bay visitors). Unfortunately, local fishermen will not fare as well, as fish, uprooted by warming oceans, move either north or further out to sea. The albacore that used to be only about 50-70 miles offshore of MB are now up in northern waters or way out to sea (maybe some fishermen will move to Canada).


In the long run, of course, the war on keeping our planet from tipping toward more weather disruptions and warming oceans is just about lost, though that was probably inevitable without full by-in for a zero-emission future which has never been the case for a majority of Americans like yourself.


-14

As a regular attender of earth day for many, many years, I am not attending the event this year based on the “I’m not going to invite you to my party because I don’t agree with you” mentality that it appears the SLO Climate Coaltion/Earth Day Comittee has embraced.


How sad that all opinions are not allowed at this event, that I see is co-sponsored by both the City of SLO and the County. Are we now to the point that just because one organization doesn’t completely agree with another, their voice is excluded – I guess so in this case.


In all transparency (which seems to be lacking for the organizers of the earth day event), I have attended one REACT Alliance Event and also spent some time on their website. Tons of information, some very interesting studies and also an excellent basic slide show. Gave me a overall understanding of what is proposed for our ocean and more worrisome to me – our local ports.


REACT Alliance seems like a “shoe-in” for earth day, but I guess not. Apparently the public at earth day is only allowed to hear with the SLO Climate Coalition deems approprate.


13

Somehow folks have concluded short-lived (5 years max) expensive giant untested floating wind turbine industrial parks that require 100’s of miles of ocean space in important historic fisheries, destructive high decibel geographic surveys with AUVs 40 meters off the bottom, 1000’s of gallons of oil based lubricants that have to be regularly changed out with 300′ Service and Operation Vessels, and fiberglass blades that send microplastics into the ocean, floating on platforms anchored with tons of steel chain 5000′ to the Essential Fish Habitat bottom, sending unreliable power after it converts in giant eyesore substations with once-thru cooling to our pristine highly used public shores thru high voltage cables that emit EMFs, frequently fail and become unburied are “Saving the Planet” are delusional. It will, if anything, destroy life, not improve life. There are “renewable energy” solutions that don’t involve selling our oceans and grid out to foreign corporations. More practical, affordable, tested and realistic is micro grid options – rooftop solar/wind and battery systems. But that would mean we wouldn’t have to purchase as much power from greedy foreign investors, oh my! that can’t stand according to the pro-wind folks.


21

Um, this opinion argues against itself…


Regardless; no one has a bigger incentive to spend money politically than a polluter… Fossil fuel industries spend literally billions every year trying to influence congress. But let’s all be friends and pretend like one side isn’t doing that while destroying the planet for their own monetary gain? Pass. If you truly supprt wanting a better environment for everyone, you’ll support Earth Fest and green energy etc.


-31

“Given REACT Alliance’s history of spreading misinformation, as well as the presence of misleading information currently on your website”


REACT Alliance’s history of saying anything(spreading misinformation) to get a win, true this.


-21