Should San Luis Obispo County change its 911 system?

October 7, 2026

By KAREN VELIE

After years of taking a slice of the medical emergency revenue pie, there is a proposal for San Luis Obispo County and its cities to adopt a public private partnership known as an alliance model that would help cement government’s ability to charge for emergencies.

There are multiple models for county ambulance services including having only private ambulance providers respond to medical emergencies such as heart attacks and seizures, the cheapest for the consumer and some say the safest. Currently, in SLO County, firefighters respond to all calls while the ambulance drivers are generally dispatched a few minutes later under the first responder fee program.

First-responder fees are a relatively modern concept, coined within the last 30 years as a way for fire departments to receive compensation for assisting the private ambulance company as the first to arrive on scene in medical emergencies. With fewer building fires, it was a way to help fund fire departments.

Built into the cost of an ambulance ride locally is the fact that San Luis Ambulance Service is facing first-responder fees of about $1,059,732 for the 2026-2027 fiscal year.

In several counties, fire departments have completely taken over emergency medical services and own and operate their own ambulances. However, with large salaries, early retirements with huge packages, this model is generally the most expensive.

Meanwhile, California increased its Medicaid payments to government-run ambulance providers at a cost to federal taxpayers. The discrepancy is huge: $360 to private ambulance companies for transport and more than $700 to government run programs.

Federal watchdogs have raised alarms about the Medicaid financing. The Trump administration is planning to tighten the rules. The Center for Medicare and Medicaid services have already proposed a rule to stop extra funding to government agencies.

“These schemes distort Medicaid’s financing structure, shift costs from states to the federal government,” wrote Mark Howell and Chris Medrano from Paragon Health Institute. “They are also fundamentally unfair because they give public providers a significant advantage over private providers.”

After 80 years of contracting with San Luis Ambulance for services, the SLO County Board of Supervisor voted last year to put the contract out to bid.

Noting the higher pay for government programs, the City of Paso Robles is seeking to replace the current program with the alliance model, which they would control. Paso Robles put out a request for proposals.

However, of the 170 ambulance companies operating in California, only American Medical Response made a bid. Ambulance companies argue the alliance model is not sustainable, with an estimated startup cost of over $12,500,000 to local governments.

Of the seven cities in SLO County, Morro Bay is the only city that rejected the plan.

Because we believe the public needs the facts, the truth, CalCoastNews has not put up a paywall because it limits readership. However, we are seeking qualification as a paper of record, which will allow us to publish public notices, this requires 5,000 paid subscribers.

Your subscription will help us to continue investigating and reporting the news.

Support CalCoastNews, subscribe today, click here.

 


Loading...
11 Comments

Privatized services are almost always the best way to go, and yes people who request these services should pay for them whether they are transported or not. When someone hiking a trail runs out of water or twist their little pinky toe they should pay, not the public, to be airlifted out if that’s their choice. This nanny state bullshit has gone too far and needs to end now.


San Luis Ambulance is duplicitous. They are never there first, always the fire department, who’s staff is generally better trained. You need to be an EMT and later a paramedic to move up the ranks.


That’s because that’s how they are dispatched – fire first, then SLAS to follow. San Luis Ambulance runs paramedics on their crews (along with EMTs) so I’m not sure what you’re saying there.


Did San Luis Ambulance request that the fire departments roll to medical aid calls to provide assistance? Or did the fire departments start doing it on their own, in order to got “mo’ money?” Local governments see these calls as revenue potential, nothing more. San Luis Ambulance is one of the best ambulance companies in the country; we would be stupid to push them aside to line the coffers of local governments, who already waste an insane amount of our money.


I knew there was a scam here somewhere.


oh PLEASE! There is no need to spend a bunch of money….just go back to doing things in a more sensible efficient way: answer the phone and get the address of the emergency. start rolling the units out immediately. stop with the snide attitude and the twenty questions.


and pull your head out and look at the writing on the computer screen:


“California increased its Medicaid payments to government-run ambulance providers at a cost to federal taxpayers. The discrepancy is huge: $360 to private ambulance companies for transport and more than $700 to government run programs.”


Like college tuition, when the government is involved, the annually ascending price for the services provided, is always guaranteed.


“Yes, it only cost “this” much last year, but we bought new trucks and equipment and increased salaries and benefits we honestly didn’t need to, so this year, dear deep pocket taxpayer funded government program, our cost to operate is “that” much more…”


There is important context missing from this discussion. For approximately 80 years, San Luis Obispo County’s ambulance transport system has operated without a countywide competitive RFP. Essential public services should be periodically evaluated to determine whether residents are receiving the best service and value possible. Competition isn’t an attack on the current provider; it’s responsible public stewardship.


The Central Coast EMS Partnership is also not a government takeover. It is a public-private model in which a private ambulance company would continue providing ambulance operations and patient care, while participating cities provide public oversight, accountability and financial transparency.


The financial distinction is important. Under the current for-profit model, profits may be distributed to private ownership. Under the Partnership model, remaining public revenue after expenses and required reserves would be reinvested into EMS improvements—not transferred into participating cities’ general funds.


Finally, the case for change isn’t based solely on opinion. The County’s independent EMS assessment identified opportunities to improve dispatch, ambulance deployment, system integration and performance reporting. It found that 80.5% of medical calls were dispatched as emergencies, while only 9.6% of those patients were ultimately transported with lights and sirens, and recommended implementation of a modern Emergency Medical Dispatch system.


There are things the current system does well. There are also independently documented opportunities to improve it. That is exactly why a competitive process is appropriate.


The discussion about the future of ambulance service in San Luis Obispo County deserves a complete picture.


There is an important fact that should not be lost in this debate: essential public services should be periodically evaluated to ensure residents are receiving the best service and value possible. For approximately 80 years, the County’s ambulance transport system has operated without a competitive RFP process. The incumbent provider has therefore not had to compete through an open countywide procurement process to demonstrate that its service model, pricing, technology, and performance represent the best available option. Competition is not an attack on an existing provider. It is responsible public stewardship. No provider of an essential public service should be insulated from periodically having to demonstrate its value to the communities it serves.


Additionally, the proposed system is not a government takeover of ambulance service. The Central Coast EMS Partnership is a public-private model where a private ambulance company would continue to provide day-to-day ambulance operations, staffing, equipment, and patient care. Participating local cities would provide public oversight, accountability, and financial transparency.


The fundamental difference is what happens with the system’s finances. Under the current for-profit model, profits generated by ambulance operations are ultimately distributed to private ownership. Under the Partnership model, after operating expenses and required reserves, remaining public revenue would be reinvested into the EMS system, not transferred into participating cities’ general funds like some online are suggesting.


Those funds could support additional ambulance resources, improved dispatch, technology and other EMS improvements, with oversight by representatives of the participating cities.


There are also documented reasons to consider change. The County’s independent EMS assessment identified significant opportunities for improvement in dispatch, ambulance deployment, system integration, and performance reporting. Most notably, 80.5% of medical calls were dispatched as emergencies, while only 9.6% of those patients were ultimately transported with lights and sirens. The consultants concluded this creates unnecessary risk and recommended implementation of a modern Emergency Medical Dispatch system.


The assessment also found six dispatch centers operating at different levels, resulting in inefficiencies, inconsistent approaches, and potential delays, while fire, EMS, and dispatch lacked visibility of all system resources.


Questions about startup costs, reimbursement, and long-term financial sustainability are legitimate and should be scrutinized. But those questions should be evaluated using documented assumptions and through the competitive procurement process, not presented as settled conclusions before that process is complete.


The choice is not simply between a local ambulance company and a large corporation. It is whether ambulance operations should continue under the existing model or operate within a publicly accountable regional system where participating cities provide oversight and excess public revenue is reinvested into EMS.


There are things the current system does well. There are also significant, independently documented opportunities to improve it. That is why this conversation is happening.


It’s very clear what’s really going on. Bureaucrats always think they can do a better job. They never can. Ever. San Luis Ambulance IS reinvesting in the EMS system: they have modern equipment, reliable ambulance vehicles, and highly-trained staff. The fire chiefs just want to build their little empires, increasing their staff and their authority. This is just step one, you only need to look at Santa Barbara County to see where this leads next – Fire buying a bunch of ambulances in secret, hiding them from the public, then taking over the entire EMS system.


Public safety, the biggest fleecing of the taxpayer since public healthcare. So it turns out only 10 percent of medical calls for service are emergencies in this county. The 80 recent should pay. Nine one one what’s your credit card number?