Under fire, SLO City Manager Whitney McDonald resigning

November 11, 2026

San Luis Obispo City Manager Whitney McDonald

By KAREN VELIE

San Luis Obispo City Manager Whitney McDonald announced plans to resign between now and mid-January during a city council meeting on Tuesday. McDonald is hoping to pursue a career in psycho therapy.

“After a lot of deep reflection, I have some bitter sweet news to convey,” McDonald said wiping tears from her face. “I made the difficult decision to pursue a new career and to resign as city manager.”

In 2023, the city hired McDonald for the assistant city manager position. A year later, the city council asked her to serve as city manager.

During the past six months. McDonald has been under fire for allegedly violating laws and mismanagement.

In 2025, the San Luis Obispo County Grand Jury found that San Luis Obispo had failed to protect its residents from loud and ruckus parties hosted by Cal Poly State University students. In addition. the city also failed to enforce permit requirements for rowdy fraternities while it increased the cost of appealing those permits.

On June 13, 2025, the Grand Jury sent McDonald and Mayor Erica Stewart a copy of the report that included a lengthy list of recommendations and a warning that it was a violation of the law to share the report. Both McDonald and Stewart then shared the report.

McDonald shared the report with approximately a half-dozen city employees.

Even though the city has an ordinance making it unlawful for any person to willfully or negligently make “any noise which disturbs the peace and quiet of any neighborhood or which causes any discomfort or annoyance to any reasonable person of normal sensitivity in the area,” the city has failed to fully enforce the law, according to the Grand Jury report.

Multiple residents have voiced concerns that the city did not properly respond to the Grand Jury. It was expected the incoming Grand Jury, which was seated on July 1, would review the city’s actions which includes McDonald texting a Cal Poly administrator during the Grand Jury investigation to “align” their stories.

McDonald is also battling a lawsuit that accuses her of mismanagement.

On June 12, San Luis Obispo’s former chief building official filed a whistleblower lawsuit against the city and McDonald. Michael Loew’s suit describes a “sustained campaign to silence, punish, and ultimately force him out” after he refused to “participate in unlawful conduct.”

The city council plans to meet in closed session on Friday to develop a plan to fill the city manager position both in the short term and the long term.

Because we believe the public needs the facts, the truth, CalCoastNews has not put up a paywall because it limits readership. However, we are seeking qualification as a paper of record, which will allow us to publish public notices, this requires 5,000 paid subscribers.

Your subscription will help us to continue investigating and reporting the news.

Support CalCoastNews, subscribe today, click here.

 


Loading...
53 Comments

What about Stewart, the ring leader and CalPoly connection? Criminal prosecution, recall election or sit back and let the council hire the next partner in crime?


She literally has a Juris Doctorate (a law degree). She knew exactly what she was doing.


The San Luis Obispo City Firefighters, IAFF Local 3523, have issued a statement:


The resignation of City Manager Whitney McDonald marks a turning point fo the city, and the Local 3523 receives the news with cautious hope. We take no satisfaction in any public servant’s departure, but a change in leadership is a chance to step back, reassess, and chart a better course. We intend to meet that moment with an open hand.


For some time, our Local has raised serious concerns about how labor matters are handled at City Hall, including directives that discouraged our members from speaking openly about their working conditions and conflicts of interest that arise when the officials who are the subject of a complaint refuse to recuse themselves. We have pressed those concerns through the proper legal channels, and we will continue to do so, always with the aim of fair treatment for the firefighters who serve this community.


A new City Manager brings a fresh set of eyes and the chance to rebuild the trust that effective pubic safety requires. Local 3523 welcomes the chance and stands ready to work in good faith with the City to repair these relationships and to put the Department’s energy back where it belongs, serving the people of San Luis Obispo.


Thank you. It’s on their Facebook page:


https://www.facebook.com/SanLuisObispoCityFirefightersLocal3523


There’s also a statement from late September that criticizes the City Attorney, Christine Dietrick, for trying to silence them and turn their own union against them.


Whitney McDonald, Christine Dietrick were also named in the whistleblower lawsuit filed against the City, along with Scott Collins and Timmi Tway. It seems there needs to be a deep cleaning at City Hall so it can get back to serving the people who live in SLO.


They need to fire Christine Dietrick immediately. Everytime I go to a SLO city Council meeting and see that goon there, it brings such shame on the entire room. They’re both CROOKS.


Holy shit, there sure was a lot of coded language in that statement. It’s all true too.


Of course the firefighters union is concerned about a “public servant” losing their job. They only care about how much they can bilk from the tax payer and which city manager will bend over backwards to pay their absurd salaries


That’s a lot of colorful prose to state your position on ethics. Yet, as a Union, you will vote for these same unethical people over and over again. Yes, I know it’s because democrats will gleefully increase your salaries, but only to the point of being financially unsustainable, due to the heavy increase in taxes to pay for you and their socialist programs (pograms?).


Any “new” city manager, will be drawn from the same pool as the last, soaked in the same political and financial aspect.


Good to hear the firefighters are standing for free speech. Is there a connection here with former fire chief Tuggle who retired after major issues with Grossman’s development and his failure to inspect or charge the fire meters that came to light when several homes under construction caught fire? Oh, and there’s more. The City then made him a consultant. So now Tuggle gets paid twice! His retirement and his consulting fees. Double pay for double failures? Really?


Firefighters love this grift and will never speak ill of their “brother” milking the taxpayers


We agree with your assessment but have no sympathy for the most coddled group of opportunistic and self-serving public servants in the county.


It’s almost as if there are only 10 people in top jobs in the entire county and they simply move around as they fail in one position after the other. No doubt the city has their head hunter out with the following criteria in this order: Democrat, Woman, POC, lesbian or other and lastly, meets minimum qualifications.


Zero mention of any controversy or lawsuit in the Tom Fulks sanitized and city council approved Tribune article. However, if you want to read front page articles on the debate regarding merging the Carrboro and Chapel Hill police departments or the closure of the Hillsborough Street location of a fusion restaurant in Raleigh, CCN is sorely lacking. Good thing we’ve got the otherwise useless Tribune for our North Carolina news.


So, was Loews case with the City ever settled? I can’t seem to find the outcome of his Law suit? But after seeing affiliating articles, IT’s really disturbing to see his wife being brought into the mess. For what reason? Was badmouthing his wife another attempt at punishment? The Jan Marx painting the curb event was just as insane!

But at least It’s great to think things are looking up, with the break up of the “We will do what we want despite what’s right, Club”.


The lawsuit shows active on the Superior Court website. Discovery/depositions should be happening now or shortly based on the timing of the litigation. Whitney McDonald will still have to sit for a deposition, even if she resigned from her job. Same with city attorney Christine Dietrick, Assistant City Manager Scott Collins and Community Development Director Timmi Tway.


The truth always comes out.


The city is hoping that pushing the city manager out will somehow protect them (and city taxpayers) from the consequences of the POS city manager now being forced out. No one believes the lies of the city manager explains why she is resigning. Reminds me former mayor Heidi Harmon


Yes it does!! Can’t wait to hear how they answer to this one! The one good thing, as we saw with Adam Hill, (not that I want anyone to do themselves under because of the Truth being revealed). But that the Truth will come out! I do hope Loews is happier in Lompoc. A Lot less Drama?? SLO seems to be the capital of Drama. They even read about SLO Drama back East during the Adam Hill Saga. I swear we would make a good Netflix series, just based on all the Drama and corruption that’s gone on in this County with our officials!


The entire city council is backed by the local chapter of the Democratic party.


I like Jan Marx, a lot. She was the only council member with any integrity and balls to refer the sleezy mayor to the personell board to be potentially censored


Maybe so, but what about painting the curb to diss her neighbor?


Don’t be fooled by Marx. She simply sees the writing on the wall and is pretending innocence. She has plenty of dirty tricks in her history.


…or…”we will do what we want despite what’s legal.”


You should read the KSBY articles on her resignation, she is painted in glowing terms without a single reference to the whistleblower lawsuit she got named in as a defendant.


Its a requirement, though she is incompetent, she does know about the failures of others in the administration, so the glowing send off is so she will keep her mouth shut. Very common in government, fail to the top, but everything is kept hush hush, so the failure can just move on to another job.


I like that guy’s Alfred E. Neuman haircut.


The City will soon begin a nationwide search for a new City Manager. Among the top qualifications they are seeking is that they are a female person of color, and/or a member of the pride community.


Exactly, and willing to screw every person they can over for tax revenue.


Indeed, a nationwide search at an expense of tens of thousands of dollars, only to hire the person sitting at the next desk.


awwww, do women, people of color and members of the pride community hurt your feelings?


It’s about having someone honest, competent, and qualified which means your pets shouldn’t be hired


DEI level one, absolutely.


#PersonalResponsibility

#Meritocracy


MLKJ knew that long ago.


They usually receive their pussy pass and zero accountability.