Mason finally free as DA won’t retry case
October 18, 2012
John Ryan Mason
The District Attorney’s office announced Thursday that it will not retry San Luis Obispo firefighter John Ryan Mason who allegedly assaulted a man in a bar bathroom last year [Tribune].
Mason’s felony assault trial ended last month with a hung jury leaning eight to four in favor of acquittal. In an announcement Thursday, prosecutors indicated that the deadlock in the case would be too difficult to overcome.
“After an evaluation of all the evidence and absent the discovery of new or additional evidence, our office has determined that it will not retry the case,” Chief Deputy District Attorney Jerret Gran said.
Mason, who recently received consideration for San Luis Obispo employee of the year, faced charges of felony assault with great bodily injury and battery with serious bodily injury. Mason, 35, engaged in a bathroom brawl at Pappy McGregor’s Bar & Grill with Jory Brigham, 33, following a wedding both had attended in June 2011. Brigham suffered 17 facial fractures from the fight.
But, the defense claimed Brigham did not divulge credible testimony as a witness. Defense attorney Chris Casciola credited Brigham changing his story about not having a flask the night of the incident as a primary reason for the majority of the jurors voting to acquit Mason.
Print 
PDF
Bottom line is that Jory shouldn’t have lied. If he will lie about having a flask, then he will lie about other things and that doesn’t make him look so innocent. If I were on a jury and was convinced that he had a flask and he was out-right lying to me about it, then I would wonder what else he did that day that he was lying about. Jurors don’t like to be lied to. Everybody already knew that he was drunk, so he just needed to admit that. As a juror, I would understand that maybe he had a flask because he couldn’t afford the price of the drinks. We’ve all probably had too much to drink at times and we know that this doesn’t mean that we don’t know/remember exactly what happened, it just means our behavior wasn’t exactly stellar . I think Casicola is right, Jory lost because Jory lied.
Like or Dislike:
8 
2
Chris Casciola (& Stein) is an excellent attorney!
Maybe Jory Brigham got what he deserved (but not to that degree or power) and maybe not.
Trying to make sense of it all leads to flaw seeking.
The greatest flaw was SLOPD’s one week delay in the arrest (because safety officers can do no wrong?)
Like or Dislike:
2 
2
If I ever have a need to call 911 and the Fire Department is dispatched to my home, I hope it will NOT be “Firefighter” Mason … especially if he is having a bad day or angry at someone, I cannot afford the medical bills or home repairs.
Like or Dislike:
13 
3
Lesson learned… if you want to commit a felony, get a job working for government first. Worst case: you go back work after paid administrative leave. Best case: you retire early with a hefty pension.
Like or Dislike:
23 
7
Hidden due to low comment rating Click here to see.
Poorly-rated. Like or Dislike:
17 
55
I don’t think that I spoke out on this subject but I might have voted for acquittal too. The reason is that there was “reasonable doubt” as to his guilt. On the other hand, in a civil trial I might vote against him because I think it somewhat more likely than not that he was guilty.
Like or Dislike:
19 
13
The civil trial might end differently, especially if a fireman is not selected to serve on the jury as was done in the previous trial
Hot debate. What do you think?
33 
5
seems to me the jury in the OJ case looked at all the evidence too … bottom line is that this guy crossed the line and got away with it. It will be interesting to see if the City retains him because he definately violated the cities code of ethics … not that the officials follow them anyway.
Well-loved. Like or Dislike:
38 
2
I’ve got a question for you slojustice. What is your opinion what happened? Don’t dodge it and say it doesn’t matter, or it’s over, or the best you don’t have an opinion. I have never meet anyone when asked about something going on, that doesn’t have a opinion or view of their own.
Was it self defence? Was the damage caused by Jory hitting his head on the sink?
Everyone here has at least taken the courage to express an opinion right or wrong. What say you????
Like or Dislike:
14 
1
I think Brigham and Mason got into a fight and Brigham lost. It takes two to tango. And if you go looking for a fight, chances are you will get one.
Like or Dislike:
8 
7
True. Two guys in that bathroom are the only ones who know what happened. There was a fight for sure.
So you didn’t mention if you thought he hit his head or not. If he hit his head o.k. but if he was damaged by Mason, WHY did Mason, if self defence as he claims, keep beating on Jory to the point of damage done?
Like or Dislike:
10 
1
According to witness testimony, the whole thing was done in a matter of seconds.
Like or Dislike:
1 
2
slojustice, you’ve got it right when you notice this is a “lynch mob.”
The prevalence of “thumbs down” votes on the posts based on rational thought vs. the “thumbs up” votes on the posts based on blathering vitriol clearly show the overwhelming lack of any capacity for levelheadedness amongst many of the readers.
Like or Dislike:
5 
11
Just like the cops who beat Rodney King were innocent of beating him.
It’s amazing what public safety workers can get away with.
Like or Dislike:
11 
4