Coronavirus shutdown shows dust on the Nipomo Mesa science is flawed

May 25, 2020

A view of the Nipomo Mesa from the Oceano Dunes State Vehicular Recreation Area

By KAREN VELIE

Excessive dust days have more than doubled since RVs and off-road vehicles were barred from the Oceano Dunes, data from two Nipomo Mesa air quality monitoring sites show. California State Parks closed the Oceano Dunes State Vehicular Recreation Area to all off-road and recreational vehicles on March 28 because of the coronavirus pandemic.

The air quality data called into question the San Luis Obispo County Air Pollution Control District’s theory, disputed by California state scientists, that off-road riding activities cause high dust levels detected on the Nipomo Mesa. This theory generally ignores that Oceano Dunes lies within a larger complex of coastal sand dunes created by wind blowing sand from the shoreline.

For years, the APCD and Nipomo Mesa residents have clashed with state parks and off-road vehicle riders over the cause of dust in the air at the Nipomo Mesa. Both sides agree strong westerly winds blowing over the sand dunes transport dust to the mesa.

In 2018, California State Parks entered into a stipulated order of abatement with the APCD. The agreement mandates that the state reduce wind-blown dust, specifically dust particles that are 10 microns or less in diameter, on the Nipomo Mesa by 50 percent. Despite agreeing to the various terms in the agreement, state parks still denies that off-roading causes the dust on the mesa.

Access denied: Approximately 50 acres of camping and beach area closed off for APCD dust projects.

The  primary goal of the agreement is to ensure that concentrations of dust measured on the mesa stay within federal and state standards, as measured at two of the APCD’s air monitoring sites on the mesa, which are known as “CDF – Arroyo Grande” and “Nipomo-Guadalupe Road.”

Overall, the state has spent approximately $14 million in tax payer revenue in the last 10 years to reduce dust concentrations on the mesa. The state covered more than 150 acres of dune sand with vegetation or orange plastic fencing. Additional dune-covering projects are anticipated in the coming months and years, under the theory that the obstructions would help reduce dust produced by the blowing sand.

In January, State Parks Director Lisa Mangat shut down approximately half of the camping area and about 5 percent of the riding area at the Oceano Dunes, or approximately 50 acres near the shoreline. The area was popular with campers, and provided 50 percent of the park’s camping availability.

CalCoastNews examined archived data from wind and dust measurements collected from the two Nipomo Mesa air quality monitoring sites to determine if State Parks’ mandated efforts along with the closure of the park in March would lead to a reduction in dust concentrations.

Specifically, reporters examined the number of daily exceedances of state and federal air quality standards during the month of May for the past six years at the two monitoring sites. The CDF site is approximately 2.5 miles from the dune shoreline, on the southwest edge of Nipomo Mesa. The Nipomo-Guadalupe Road site is about four miles from the shore, on the lower edge of the mesa. Agricultural lands lie between the coastal dunes and the Nipomo Mesa.

The parameters were chosen because May is typically the windiest month in south San Luis Obispo County, and 2015 predates the various dune-covering operations undertaken by State Parks.

Wind data indicates that May’s average wind speed at the two monitoring sites has varied little from year to year. At the CDF site, the May winds average at about 5 miles per hour, and at the Nipomo-Guadalupe Road site, the winds are slightly stronger, averaging about 5.5 miles per hour.

The number of exceedances of California’s air quality standard for airborne dust tells a different story. At both of the air monitoring stations, a substantially greater number of May exceedances occurred this year compared to the other years, even though there have been no recreational vehicles on the dunes; and the month of May has not yet ended.

For example, at the CDF site in May 2019, there were six exceedances, but this year, as of May 22, the exceedances have doubled to 12. At the Nipomo-Guadalupe Road site in May 2019, there were only three exceedances, but as of May 22, exceedances have nearly quadrupled to 11.

As part of the agreement, a panel of scientific advisors, known as the Scientific Advisory Group (SAG), was formed to assist in the design and implementation of the various dune-covering projects. The SAG is led by William Nickling, an emeritus professor at the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada.

In apparent anticipation that continued high-dust days with no vehicle recreation in the dunes would cause confusion, on April 6, Dr. Nickling and other SAG members authored a memorandum regarding the vehicle closure at Oceano Dunes and possible changes in dune dust emissions.

“It is the opinion of the SAG that the accumulated impact of OHV [off highway vehicle] activity remains a significant contributor to observed PM [dust] emissions at ODSVRA, even during this period in which the ODSVRA is temporarily closed to recreational uses,” according to the memorandum. “The SAG acknowledges that the Oceano Dunes are a naturally dusty surface that would experience PM emissions even in the absence of human activity, especially during this spring windy season. But the SAG is also clearly aware that decades of OHV activity have fundamentally altered the natural beach-dune landscape, making the dunes significantly more susceptible to PM emissions than they would be in a natural state.”

However, the SAG memorandum fails to explain how the dunes have been “fundamentally altered” to emit more dust, and also why the SAG did not anticipate the number of state exceedances for dust to substantially increase in the absence of vehicle recreation on the dunes.

One theory is that the recreational vehicles that used to park on the dunes, helped obstruct the wind flow.

Sign up for breaking news, alerts and updates with the Cal Coast News Top Stories.


Loading...

42
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
October

The APCD has been very quiet on this matter ever since they announced they were going to use this opportunity to study it. Now it’s obvious why. Thank you CCN for keeping us informed.


ratherbefishing

They’ll link the higher dust to climate change and claim they were correct


KAG2020

Good report Karen. People in management in this state from state government to federal government seem hellbent on closing access, little by little, to EVERYTHING. The closure of the Los Padres NF(Monterey District) the past couple of months is absolutely assinine. The dune closures are not backed by science as Karen pointed out, roads on BLM land that have been open for 30 years with NO excessive eroision being closed. I, for one, am damn tired of it!


Two local agencies that HAVE to go are the ACPD and IWMA. Remember the stupid IWMA jamming the bag ban down our throats and forcing us into “reusable bags”? Well now the reusable bags are banned because they transmit germs and bacteria. We tried to tell these idiots at the IWMA but no, they wouldn’t listen.


Kevin Rice

Nickling is a FAKE (emeritus) Ph.D.??? Unbelievable!!! APCD junk science!


shelworth

We all know it had nothing to do with dust, it had to do with certain people just didn’t want to see anyone using internal combustion engines to have fun. That’s it.


mercut1469

Excellent article, Ms. Velie. I tend to agree that using the dunes for off road recreation has not created any more dust than would have been produced by nature. In the late 60’s through the late 70’s I farmed a piece of land just below the Mesa a few miles east of Oceano and there were days when the dust was particularly bad and this was well before the idiots (oh, sorry, recreationalists) started driving their machines out there in any large number. Some days I would be so full of grit and dirt that I would spend a half hour in the shower after work.


Every once in a while, and on July 4, there would be lots of people out there but nothing like the throng that shows up out there now on a regular basis. I believe that more long term study needs to be done on this topic, but I have always been skeptical of the claims by locals that their health was in jeopardy. I’m sure I would have been dead long ago if that were the case. Seems a simple case of NIMBYism in my opinion. The biggest threat to anyone’s health out there is for some drunk idiot (sorry, recreationalist) to come flying over a dune and run you over.


TKG

Leave it to the best investigative journalism at CCN to peel back the onion and reveal the truth, but it’s highly unlikely that the Monarch Dunes NIMBYs will ever be able to handle the truth. Well done CCN.


commonsenseguy

This gosh darn pandemic. It exposed another flawed environmentalist theory. What, the dust will still blow around without off road vehicles? That can’t be. Gosh darn Mother nature. You out smarted us again. Kind of reminds of another. Now that you can’t take your mandated reusable bags to the grocery store for now, many stores are what? Giving you plastic bags for free. Take that Jim “plastic bag band” Patterson”.


CHnemo

So no plants have grown back…………


kayaknut

Just like if there were no people living in Trilogy or the Mesa area there would be fewer complaints about dust.


1 2 3 4