A crooked road to Arroyo Grande?

October 21, 2014
Mayor Tony Ferrara

Mayor Tony Ferrara

Editor’s note: The Arroyo Grande ordinance limiting how the mayor and city council members may legally interact with city staff is at the bottom of this story.

By KAREN VELIE and DANIEL BLACKBURN

Business owners and city staffers in Arroyo Grande have come out with accusations of graft and corruption by Mayor Tony Ferrara and other city and county officials.

The charges leveled against Ferrara and others include theft of public resources by public officials, threats and harm to political opponents using city resources, attempts to get kickbacks from contractors and misspending city money to support a favored developer.

Ferrara also is the newly-elected president of the League of California Cities. He did not respond to detailed questions from CalCoastNews.

As a member of the Arroyo Grande City Council, Ferrara is permitted by state and city laws to work with the council to set policy — and then may instruct only the city manager to carry out the council’s orders. Mayors and council members are prohibited by law from acting alone in giving orders to the city manager, or from instructing other city employees to do their bidding.

But several developers, business owners and Arroyo Grande employees accuse Ferrara of ordering staff to do work for him using city equipment. California law makes the personal use of equipment and city staff for personal use a crime, theft of public services.

On Sept. 27, Ferrara had three public works employees, two city trucks and one city backhoe at his home to remove a pear tree that had fallen over. The team cut up the tree and took the wood to the city corporate yard for disposal. A week earlier, Ferrara had another public works employee at his home moving a television set from his living room to his garage, employees said.

Tony Ferrara's fallen pear tree.

Tony Ferrara’s fallen pear tree.

Shortly after CalCoastNews began asking about the use of public services for his private home, the city issued a bill to Ferrara asking for $196 for the tree removal. The bill came on Oct. 6 and Ferrara paid the bill on Oct. 10.

Three days later Ferrara told the city council that he had been charged a hefty fee for the removal of the tree. But a half dozen local tree specialists gave estimates all starting at a higher rate than the mayor paid the city.

City Clerk Kelly Wetmore explained why the city had staff work on private property saying that because a portion of the tree was on the sidewalk, the city was responsible for its removal.

However, Commander Kevin McBride, a 30-year veteran on the Arroyo Grande Police Department, said that in some cases city employees will remove a limb dangerously obstructing the sidewalk. But city staff does not chop up and remove entire trees for homeowners, he said.

Last week, CalCoastNews contacted public works staff at five local cities. Each of the staff said that, in their city, removal of a tree was the homeowner’s responsibility. However, if a dangerous situation has been created and the homeowner is not able to remove a sidewalk obstruction, those cities will remove limbs covering the sidewalk, and require the homeowner to remove the remainder of the tree.

In addition to allegations of theft of public services, business owners accuse city officials of using threats of withholding contracts in order to promote their political opponents and squelch critics.

Several mayoral elections ago, one of Ferrara’s critics had SLOCO Data and Printing print and mail out pamphlets that painted a negative picture of Ferrara.

Julie Tizzano, the owner of the Arroyo Grande business, said she was approached by Councilman Jim Dickens and told that if she did not mail out a correction, she would no longer do business with the city. She refused Dickens’ demand.

“They threatened me for political gain,” Tizzano said. “Aside from several small jobs that only I have data for, I never received another job from the city.”

Other business owners contend Ferrara works with the city manager, city attorney, and community development director in a convoluted, dysfunctional fashion that has cost those owners millions of dollars. Most said their biggest problem has been receiving specific directions from staff, complying with those directions, and then having city officials or other staffers change the direction delaying the project adding to costs for the developer.

Many say they will not work in the city of Arroyo Grande as long as Adams and Ferrara are in charge.

About 10 years ago, former Community Development Director Rob Strong promoted several changes to the city’s general plan to alter land use policies. Several months later, he entered into a short-term escrow on a property that included a large parcel of land and two older homes, known as the Cherry Creek property. Strong did not have the money to purchase the property, according to a disclosure that he made.

Strong then contacted San Luis Obispo businessman Cliff Branch and recommended Branch develop the Cherry Creek property with a neighboring property owner, Branch told CalCoastNews in an email. The development required Branch to carry on a dialogue with Ferrara, Adams and City Attorney Tim Carmel, he wrote.

“Over the course of a year, we communicated extensively about the project,” Branch said in an email. “As the months passed, I realized I had landed in the twilight zone of the city government, where I felt continually misled, misinformed and/or intimidated.”

During the period, Ferrara sought a meeting, Branch wrote.

“At one point, Mayor Ferrara asked to ‘meet privately,’ and the two of us sat alone in the council chamber,” Branch wrote. “The mayor proceeded to give me a stern lecture on how to conduct myself during ‘his council meetings’ and strongly implied that it would be inadvisable to ignore his advice.

Strong later asked Branch to provide him with a purchase agreement for a lot with one of the existing homes on the Cherry Creek property at a favorable rate. He told Branch that he supervised the Arroyo Grande staffer who would be the city planner on the project. City planners can either expedite permits and other requirements or delay and possible destroy projects.

“It had always been a questionable situation because the city planning director had negotiated an option to purchase an existing house in the development, at a set price, which was highly unusual,” Branch said.

The city took no action, Branch said.

“The planning director warranted that he had made all proper disclosures to city officials. Ferrara had later said that it was ‘not an issue’ because a disclosure form was filed and approved by the city attorney,” Branch told CalCoastNews.

About seven years ago, while the project was still in the approval process, Strong left the city and the developers began working with Adams and Teresa McClish, the city’s new planning director.

“It was my impression that Adams simply ‘took orders’ from Ferrara, so a bad situation became even more dysfunctional,” Branch wrote. “It was also my experience that that City Attorney Tim Carmel conducted the city’s legal affairs with remarkable arrogance. Mr. Carmel once stormed out of a meeting called by the city in a truculent fashion while other city staff members remained at the table, stunned by the city attorney’s behavior.”

In the end, San Luis Obispo County Supervisor Caren Ray, a former Arroyo Grande city official who was involved in the projects approvals, purchased the home that Strong had optioned. By that time, the home had undergone extensive remodeling.

Then, on March 4, 14 days before the closing of Ray’s home, the Arroyo Grande Planning Commission, which includes Ray’s live-in boyfriend Randy Russom, noted an administrative decision in the meeting minutes to designate the recently purchased home as historical.

Because of the Mills Act, this decision will lower Ray’s property taxes by as much as 90 percent as compensation for limiting future remodeling and construction work on the home.

Several years ago, Rick Loughead, another prolific developer and the owner of Dolphin Bay in Shell Beach, was working on a project in the village area of Arroyo Grande. However, because of issues with misdirection from city officials and staff which stalled project approvals, Loughhead said he sold the project at a loss and that he will no longer work with the city.

“It was a difficult and convoluted deal with Ferrara, Adams, and the planning director,” Loughead said. “I couldn’t work with them and I sold the property.”

In 2004, when John and Beatrice Spencer agreed to convert a vacant building in Arroyo Grande into a Spencer’s Fresh Market, they did so at a cost of several million dollars with assurance from the city that the Courtland Place parcel across the street would include courtyards and small size shops and not a large supermarket, John Spencer said. However, several years later, developer Nick Tompkins began negotiating a deal to place a large discount grocery across the street with the city manager’s support — prompting the Spencers to close their Arroyo Grande store.

In 2011, Doug DeBerti approached city planners to get pre-approval for his plan to put a surf shop in the former home of J.J.’s Market. After receiving assurance from McClish that the project would sail through quickly, he purchased the building from Tompkins.

ag mura 3

The mural the city denied and then approved.

Then city officials asked DeBerti to share his parking lot with Tompkins and he declined.

“After that things went south,” DeBerti said.

Nine months later, city officials rejected DeBerti’s proposal because of issues they had with the driveway, as well as a mural he wanted to place on the side of the building. In the end, the building went back into Tompkins’ name. City officials then approved Tompkins’ request for the same mural and driveway that DeBerti had proposed.

“If this isn’t corruption, I don’t know what is,” DeBerti said.

City Manager Steve Adams and Teresa McClish

City Manager Steve Adams and Teresa McClish

In addition to complaints of the financial and emotional cost of attempting to deal with the city, residents question the cost to taxpayers for sweetheart deals to favored developers.

In 2010, Arroyo Grande was dealing with a deficit. The city council was looking at cutting money from after-school programs and reducing the budget for police.

The council then voted to buy the former Farm Credit building from Tompkins to use as City Hall. The $2,020,000 purchase price was almost twice the market value for the building. The council paid about $1 million too much to Tompkins, local appraisers said.

 

Arroyo Grande Ordinance 2.08.080, administrative relationships:

The council and its members shall deal with the administrative service of the city only through the city manager, except for the purposes of inquiry, and neither the council, nor any member thereof, shall give orders to any officer or employee of the city under the supervision of the city manager. The city manager shall take his or her orders and instructions only from the council as a body, and no individual member of the council shall give any order or instruction to the city manager. Any subordinate officer or employee receiving orders or instructions contrary to the provisions of this section shall report the same in writing immediately thereafter to the city manager, and the city manager shall promptly forward a copy or summary of such report to each member of the council. He or she shall likewise promptly advise each member of the council of any order or instruction received by him or her contrary to the provisions of this section. It is not intended by the provisions of this section to restrict unduly the privileges of a member of the council to request the city manager, but not any other officer or employee under his or her supervision, to prepare a report dealing with any matter of city business, or municipal affairs generally, if such report can be compiled without the undue dislocation of city activities and without the expenditure of considerable quantities of time by city personnel.

 

Don’t miss links to CalCoastNews investigations, like us on Facebook.


Loading...
MarkJames

am surprised Tony Ferrara was made the president of the California League of Cities, what a joke. The league obviously did not do its due diligence.


I wonder if they just pass the title to the good old boy has been in office the longest. He is not only an embarrassment to Arroyo Grande, but to the entire state.


agag1

Kristin apparently can plant more than trees.

She’s planting Ferrara signs!


toryrand

after this article, i have seen a few residents take those signs down. interesting. Landslide?


TacomaRose
falconbh

Just another reason we need to financially support Cal Coast News, and their loyal Advertisers .

We may not always agree,but this online newspaper supports Free Speech and Discussions that build Freedom and Democracy.


falconbh

Times Press Recorder, one of the really sad stories is how this local newspaper has shut down comments from the people,after the last tax increase election. It certainly has been missing in action during this important discussion and upcoming election. Just another example of how true freedom of the press, one of the cornerstones of democracy, has failed in their professional responsibilities. Sad day for our local newspapers.


SLOBIRD

They probably are following this fiasco but remember, these are also mayors. Birds of a feather flock together… I am sure that there might be a few good mayors but if most of them are anything like SLO County mayors (Marx, Irons, O’Malley, Piscano, Peterson, ex-mayor Shoals, Higgenbotton, not to mention members of the councils and then we have our supervisors, etc), well, enough said! They are probably all saying a Hail Mary that this never happens to them.


kayaknut

So it sounds like you think certainly the mayor if not all elected positions should have term limits?, maybe like the president, 2 terms, so for lets say the AG mayor after 4 years you are gone. Sounds good to me.


agag1

Gues who supports term limits???

That’s right!

Our Write-In candidate, Jim Hill!


AAADADDYO

Too many assumptions lead to hurting people and dont help what you are trying to do.

regardless of what you think about kristen or tim the behavoir of some people is not acceptable , she got her car keyed twice and he had paint put on his car . that does not help smart people trying to make a point.

this kind of behavior needs to stop. if those people live in AD we should be embarrassed . less meanness and more discussion on the actual issues.. That will lead to better things for the city.


agag1

Too many back room deals lead to distrust of officials. If they were open, AND God forbid, honest, THAT would lead to better things in the city. They are the leaders, when people don’t trust them, and they have given us plenty of reasons not to, they need to fix themselves and the public will follow.


SLOBIRD

Some cities have term limits in a sense. Remember will Dave Romero and Allen Settle player musical chairs? Allen was mayor and then termed out and run for councilman and Dave termed out of councilman and run for mayor. I forgot how many times they did this. I think this is Jan Marx’s and Tom O’Malley’s last terms as mayors so they will have to ran for council for be done. Any guesses?


kayaknut

So they are term limits that are not really term limits, just like Mr. Adams resignation letter that really was not a resignation letter.


falconbh

South County Voters have certainly proven to be Independent Free Voters !


Just take a look at the recent defeats of local New Tax Increases supported by our local elected representative’s of the people.


If ” We The People Vote”- we will no longer be the victims, for Charter City Power Grab, More New Tax Increases, Double Taxation, and Automatic Rate Increases.


Vote- Inform- Return Ballots – Independent


MaryMalone

“We the people” are not immune from making poor voting choices.


agag1

Does anyone know if the League of California Cities has asked Ferraro to step down?

They must be uncomfortable with their new President,

knowing that Tony’s own house is on fire down here!

Surely they MUST be following this fiasco.


panflash

Well, agag1, I hope that you’re correct, but don’t count on it. Most likely, the League staff is very uncomfortably aware of the Ferrara scandal, but chances are they are doing whatever they can to downplay it or just simply not even publicize it in any way in any communications to their member cities across the state. The top League staff probably are secretly hoping that Ferrara wins re-election as AG mayor, because if he doesn’t, THEN the League staff will have to explain to their members why they will have to replace their ousted president.


By the way, the next League of California Cities state conference is scheduled for Jan. 28-30 at the Hyatt Regency in San Francisco. If Ferrara does manage to win re-election as AG mayor, it might be interesting if hordes of angry residents show up at the League conference to demand that the League replace him as their president. Mark it on your calendars now, folks.


Side note to Ferrara: this is not over by a long stretch, pal. Even if you do somehow manage to eke out a win for another term as AG mayor, you are going to be hounded out of your position as League of California Cities president. Alternatively, of course, if you would resign now, before the Nov. 4 election, you would be able to avoid double humiliation. The ball is in your court, pal.


doglover

THANK YOU!


Citizens of Arroyo Grande.

How is this gonna end? If Ferrara is in or out, it will not be pretty. There is serious work to accomplish.


I do not believe that King Tony has the ability to heal the City.That takes empathy, listening skills and facilitation skills. Clearly the type of dominance we all have been hearing about and its shown in this article is not facilitation.


JIM HILL will have a lot of listening to do and hiring also.

The employees and POLICE need help TODAY!


Ferrara does not understand how he has ruined his jewel!


MaryMalone

QUOTING DOG LOVER: “I do not believe that King Tony has the ability to heal the City .”


I don’t believe Ferrara has any desire whatsoever to heal the city. His success at this point depends on keeping the city wounded and fractured.


———-

WTITE IN JIM HILL FOR MAYOR! (fill in the bubble)


AAADADDYO

they have not asked and beleve POA is the problem


agag1

It’s interesting that the POA has endorsed two candidates, Barbara Harmon, and Jim Hill.

Both newcomers to city politics.

Looks like more than just a few fringe residents, and business owners are lookin’ to make a change in AG.


Write-In Jim Hill for Mayor!


changes

Someone should take photos of the Vote for Jim Hill signs all over the city

and post them. Show support and inspiration to the citizens.


agag1

Post them where?


kayaknut

I did see a Jim Hill sign yesterday on Farroll, the bad thing was it was in a recycle bin prior to being picked up by a garbage truck


Mike Byrd

Actually, a thoughtful citizen also saw it. She stopped to rescue it and returned it to us.