San Luis Obispo man convicted of manslaughter and elder abuse

December 12, 2018

Christopher Skiff

A San Luis Obispo jury convicted the owner of the Manse on Marsh of manslaughter and elderly dependent abuse on Tuesday over the 2014 death of a dementia patient who walked away from the assisted living facility and was struck by a car. [Cal Coast Times]

In Dec. 2014, Mauricio Edgar Cardenas, 65, was attempting to cross Los Osos Valley Road in Los Osos when he was hit and killed by a 2010 Dodge Challenger. The CHP determined the driver was unable to avoid Cardenas because of the darkness at the location he was crossing.

The following March, state investigators raided the Manse on Marsh, as first reported by CalCoastNews. Then in July 2017, the California Attorney General’s Office charged Christopher Skiff, 54, and Gary Potts, 63, with involuntary manslaughter and elderly dependent abuse. Skiff, the owner of the Manse on Marsh, has now been convicted of the charges, while Potts, a former employee of the elderly care facility, is being tried separately.

Prosecutors alleged the Manse on Marsh admitted Cardenas as a resident, even though he had a dementia diagnosis and the facility lacked a waiver to handle such patients. The Manse on Marsh had previously been cited several times for admitting residents for whom it was not licensed to provide care, and former employees have said there were numerous dementia-diagnosed residents at the facility.

During Skiff’s trial, which began on Nov. 15, prosecutors argued the defendant ordered Manse on Marsh staff to urge a doctor to reevaluate Cardenas, who was eventually admitted to the facility with a recorded primary diagnosis of mild cognitive impairment. The prosecution called to the stand several former employees, who testified Skiff was very engaged in the operations of the facility and sales, and that he told a nurse to urge a doctor to change Cardenas’ dementia diagnosis.

Former employees testified that Skiff and facility staffers had daily meetings in which they discussed a “hot list” of prospective residents who had medical and other barriers to admission and created action plans on how to get the individuals admitted. Employees testified that they expressed concern to Skiff over Cardenas being on the hot list, but shortly later, he was admitted to the Manse on Marsh anyway.

Skiff testified in his own defense that he only learned of Cardenas’ dementia after the man’s death and that Cardenas’ name was added to the hot list at the request of his family. Skiff’s attorney, Robert Sanger, argued Cardenas had mild cognitive impairment, not dementia, when he was admitted to the Manse on Marsh and that the facility was capable of caring for him with that diagnosis.

Following three days of deliberation, the jury convicted Skiff, who now faces up to eight years in prison. Skiff is being allowed to remain out of custody until his sentencing, which is scheduled for Jan. 25.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Was Skiff instrumental in the man’s death? Is it his fault that the man died? Is justice being served? Maybe, maybe not. I don’t know.

I suspect his true crime was in stretching the state’s licensing requirements. Skiff’s conviction will serve as an example to anyone who thinks they can run their business without due deference to the state’s fees, permits, licenses and waivers.

Prosecutorial overreach?….

This is very tragic for the family of Mr. Cardenas, the driver and the Skiff family. I truly believe Mr. Skiff meant no harm despite the charges. Chris has always been man with a positive attitude, contiguous smile, strong in faith and a great leader to his family. My prayers are with all involved, healing for the family of Mr. Cardenas and the driver as well. I cant imagine what the Skiff family is processing at the moment but know you have an army of brothers & sisters praying for you and your family and that tools will be provided to work through this next challenging chapter.

Yes, prayers are all that can be said.

I’m sure Mr. Skiff meant no harm, he just wanted to squeeze a little more money out of the rest home;fancy cars, fancy homes, fancy friends and private school educations are expensive luxuries.

I’m sure his friends will rally around and persuade the justice system to give him county jail time, so that he can be assigned house arrest and electronic monitoring with an ankle tracker.